With I Am Legend currently in cinemas and, inexplicably, breaking box office records, now seemed like a good time to revisit the first, and still the best, version of Richard Matheson’s classic novel.
With a budget that was probably less than a third of what the dog in I Am Legend got paid (inflation adjusted of course) this American financed and Italian shot film manages to create more tension, more suspense and more emotion than the mega budget Will Smith starrer could even dream of. For example it’s far more effective to have Neville, or Morgan as he’s renamed here, confront his dead wife when she returns from the grave than have her die in some unnecessary CGI explosion. The big bang may look more impressive but that’s just superficial gloss. The Last Man on Earth isn’t glossy, for one thing it couldn’t afford to be, but it works on a gut level that’s far truer to the original story.
I have to admit I was a bit surprised by Will Smith’s performance, he does surprisingly well (with the exception of the Bob Marley scene) even if he is miscast. I had feared we were in for a performance like I, Robot or, heaven forbid, Independence Day, instead he’s surprisingly restrained. He can’t hold a candle to Vincent Price though.
